Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Tina Champagne 3 months ago

Ok i made a review last year.. Giving you guys a 5.. this is us.. Daughter and i drive to your location every other week.. Get a large pizza and ranch. Never do you disappoint.. BUT tonight i was a little disappointed.. you guys tell me 15 to 20 minutes. I come in after 18 minutes.. I walk in and stand by the doors. Next to me is a door dasher also waiting.. 5 minutes goes by, 10 minutes, 15 minutes goes by, Then at maybe 20minutes someone asked if we were being helped.. 6 tables and maybe 8 people in the bar area.. waitresses made eye contact with us. But noone said a word.. our pizza that we start eating in the car on our way home as we drive all the way from Janesville WI area was luke warm... disappointed.. But what really pissed me off is that the door dasher who waited longer then i did.. Had no where to sit as you had rolled up rugs on the seating area. And she was like 8 months pregnant.. Do better.. Not sure ill be making that drive for a pizza. May need to find something in WI..

Alex Reynolds 4 months ago

This was my first experience here, food had a good flavor and was fresh. Ordered their shared meal deal. 2 salad, 2 personal pan pizzas, and 2 individual deserts. The waitress was more than friendly, allowed plenty of time for the social lunch I had, and delivered hot food promptly. This would definitely be a return trip. 2 people with tip ate well enough for under $40

Jennifer Payton a year ago

Mediocre experience. Server was nice but inattentive to our table. Disappeared for lengthy time. Took 20 mins or more to get drinks. 10 mins before came to us to take order then another 10-15 mins to make 3 sodas and walk them 2 feet over to us. We were seated in the bar area. Bread sticks came out fresh, hot and were delicious. Well seasoned and perfectly cheesy . We were starving and inhaled them so fast I forgot to take a pic. Our order consisted of Spaghetti and Meatballs, BBQ Burger with tots and pizza with side cesear salad. The spaghetti came out look warm which was very disappointing. But it was very tasty and filling. Sauce was full of flavor and so were the HUGE meatballs. I can only imagine how much better it would have been hot. Would def order this again. The BBQ Burger was reported to be well cooked and yummy. It was also mildly warm when it came out. Tots were reported to be well seasoned and mildly warm also. Pizza was reported to be ok. It was also only warm. Son wasn’t too impressed with it and he loves pizza.It looked very fake… like premade frozen pizza. He didn’t eat but 2 small slices of it. Cesar salad was basic. Oddly enough the lettuce was warm inste

Rich McGee a year ago

Food was very good. The chicken caprese sandwich was one of the best sandwiches I have ever eaten. Fries were perfect. Individual sausage pizza was good (sandwich was better!). Jennifer, the server, was both charming and beautiful. Very professional service. The only complaint: the place looked like it had been hit by a tornado when we walked in. Almost every table was trashed. Maybe the bus person called off.

Andy Earle 3 years ago

My wife and I were looking for a place to eat on our last night in Rockford and we stumbled upon this establishment. I'm not so sure we made the right decision. We walked in and noticed it was about half full, which is usually a good thing on a Wednesday evening. We saw there were a few employees standing and chatting, but when they saw us, it took a few seconds for one of them to walk over and seat us. It's not a deal breaker at all, just setting up for later in this review. Our server came over rather quickly and took our drink orders, returning shortly thereafter to take our food orders as well. The pretzel sticks came out, and while they were good, the beer cheese was not served warm. Rather, it was cold, which is something we hope was either an oversight or just the way they do it there. We each got a small pizza - my wife with the Hawaiian and Me with the Thai Pie. Both pizzas were good! The Hawaiian had an ale crust that was tasty and the Thai had a sweet chili sauce that matched well with the toppings. The issue we had is with the service and the time it took to get our food and, subsequently, the check. We were sitting there for the better part of 10 minutes before our ser